Ultimate Garbage Disposal Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Garbage Disposal

Ultimate Garbage Disposal Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Garbage Disposal

A reliable garbage disposal is one of the hardest-working tools in any kitchen, simplifying cleanup and reducing food waste in landfills. With so many options available, how do you choose the right one for your home? We’re here to make the decision easier. With former plumbers on staff, we know what separates a good disposal from a great one.

We’ve created a comprehensive guide featuring five top-rated garbage disposals, each tailored to different needs and budgets. Read on to find your perfect match!


Our Top 5 Garbage Disposals

Best for High-End Kitchens and Open-Concept Homes

InSinkErator Advanced Series Pro 1000 Garbage Disposal with Cord (1 HP)

InSinkErator Advanced Series Pro 1000 Garbage Disposal with Cord (1 HP)

This 1 HP powerhouse combines ultimate performance with whisper-quiet operation, thanks to InSinkErator’s SoundSeal Technology. Its 4-Stage MultiGrind system reduces food scraps into ultra-fine particles, minimizing clogs and odors. The durable Dura-Drive induction motor and 11-year in-home warranty offer long-lasting reliability.

Best For: Open-concept kitchens or high-end homes where noise control matters. Its quiet operation lets you entertain or converse without interruptions.

Shop the InSinkErator Advanced Series Pro 1000

Best Value for Everyday Performance

InSinkErator Contractor Power Series 333 Garbage Disposal with Cord (3/4 HP)

InSinkErator Contractor Power Series 333 Garbage Disposal with Cord (3/4 HP)

Offering incredible value, the Contractor 333 features a 3/4 HP Dura-Drive induction motor and quieter performance compared to standard models. Its 2-Stage MultiGrind system ensures efficient grinding of tough food scraps, and the 7-year in-home warranty guarantees peace of mind.

Best For: Families needing reliable, everyday performance without overspending.

Shop the InSinkErator Contractor Power Series 333

Best Standard Option for Most Households

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal with Cord (3/4 HP)

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal with Cord (3/4 HP)

The Badger 5 is a trusted kitchen staple. Its 3/4 HP Dura-Drive motor and galvanized steel components ensure durability, while the compact design saves valuable under-sink space. The Quick Lock mounting system makes installation a breeze.

Best For: A dependable, no-frills option for most households. If you’re looking for a sturdy, straightforward disposal that gets the job done, look no further.

Shop the InSinkErator Badger 5

Best Durable Choice with Lifetime Warranty

Mountain Plumbing MT555-3CFWD3B Perfect Grind Waste Disposer (5/8 HP)

Mountain Plumbing MT555-3CFWD3B Perfect Grind Waste Disposer (5/8 HP)

The Perfect Grind features a 5/8 HP permanent magnet motor that provides high torque instantly, reducing jams. Its sound insulation, antimicrobial odor protection, and lifetime warranty make it a standout choice. Designed for continuous feed, it eliminates the need for manual de-jamming tools.

Best For: Homeowners seeking a quiet, durable disposal with the added assurance of a lifetime warranty.

Shop the Mountain Plumbing Perfect Grind

Best Budget-Friendly Option

Moen GXP33C Gx Pro Series Garbage Disposal (1/3 HP)

Moen GXP33C Gx Pro Series Garbage Disposal (1/3 HP)

Budget-friendly and reliable, this 1/3 HP disposal features a high-speed 1,900 RPM VORTEX permanent magnet motor, reducing the risk of jams. It includes a pre-installed power cord for easy setup and a 2-year limited warranty with in-home service.

Best For: Light use or tight budgets. While not as powerful as higher-end models, it offers excellent reliability for basic kitchen tasks.

Shop the Moen Gx Pro Series


Bonus Tip: Make Any Disposal Septic Safe

InSinkErator Bio-Charge Boost Injection System

InSinkErator Bio-Charge Boost Injection System

Worried about your septic system? You don’t need a specialized septic-safe disposal! The InSinkErator Bio-Charge Boost Injection System transforms any continuous feed disposal into a septic-friendly unit. It injects millions of microorganisms into your disposal, breaking down food waste and maintaining septic health.

Learn more about the Bio-Charge System


Whether you’re upgrading your kitchen or replacing an old unit, finding the right garbage disposal doesn’t have to be overwhelming. At Plumbing Deals, we’ve got something for every home and budget. If you have questions, feel free to contact our team—we’re here to help!